The Markets at Shrewsbury

The Markets at Shrewsbury pairs its 19-vendor Amish market lineup with monthly cruise nights hosted by the Motor Menders Rod & Custom Club, giving this Glen Rock stop a rhythm that goes beyond grocery shopping alone. Inside, the focus stays on local Amish produce and meat, homemade baked goods, crafts, clothing, and Pennsylvania Dutch food stands rather than a single-product market. That mix gives the place a clear identity: you can pick up tomatoes or peaches, order a made-to-order sub, and leave with furniture, décor, or clothing from shops that operate under the same roof.

Why it matters locally

The Markets at Shrewsbury describes itself as a local Amish farmers' market in Pennsylvania with 19 unique vendors offering produce, meat, baked goods, crafts, and clothing. That breadth matters because the market combines everyday food shopping with trades and goods tied to the surrounding Pennsylvania Dutch and Amish economy, from butcher-cut meats and deli staples to handmade furniture and outdoor structures.

The market also serves as a recurring event site, not just a row of stalls. Its calendar includes monthly cruise nights from April through October, community yard sales on the grassy field on the hill, and an annual spring auction featuring furnishings and structures from Penn Dutch Furniture, Cozy Home Gifts & Décor, and Penn Dutch Structures.

What you'll find there

The mix here runs wider than a produce-first market. Food is the anchor, but several merchants push the experience into pantry stocking, lunch pickup, home goods, and large-format Amish craftsmanship sold alongside the edible staples.

• -Find berries, tomatoes, watermelon, peaches, and other seasonal produce at Glick's Produce.
• -Order made-to-order sandwiches or subs at The Luncheonette at Country Style Family Deli.
• -Pick up cured hickory and applewood bacon, Canadian bacon, scrapple, and made-to-order subs from Country Style Family Deli.
• -Choose USDA Prime and Choice meats plus homemade specialty cuts at Country Style Fresh Meats.
• -Sip small-batch craft spirits, including rums, vodkas, gin, and fruit liqueur moonshines, from Old Republic Distillery.
• -Browse sugar-free pies and cupcakes and gluten-free bars, whoopie pies, and cakes at Ruthie's Bakery.
• -Grab made-from-scratch, hand-rolled soft Amish pretzels and pretzel sticks from Olde Fashioned Pretzel Haus.
• -Stock the pantry with pumpkin puree, applesauce, watermelon rinds, peaches, and pears from Sara's Jar Goods.
• -Get BBQ, including pressure-fried chicken and slow-roasted pulled pork, at That Pig Place.
• -Pick from ready-made wraps or salads such as strawberry spinach, Cobb, and 7-Layer options at The Salad Shack.
• -Shop handmade Amish furniture and gifts, including custom-designed solid wood pieces, at Penn Dutch Furniture.
• -Look over sheds, garages, pergolas, gazebos, swing sets, horse barns, and chicken coops from Penn Dutch Structures.
• -Browse frames, gift items, handmade soy candles, and artwork at Cozy Home Gifts & Décor.

Cruisin' At The Markets brings a Motor Menders Rod & Custom Club cruise night once a month from April through October, and Cruise Nights at The Markets At Shrewsbury fill the parking lot with hundreds of custom vehicles on the fourth Friday of the month.

Know before you go

No dogs are allowed, which is the clearest policy detail to know before planning your visit. The market sits directly off Route I-83 at 12025 Susquehanna Trail South, a useful detail if you're folding it into a longer drive through southern York County. Parking areas also double as event space: cruise nights use the market parking lot, while community yard sales are hosted on the grassy field on the hill, with visitors directed to make a left at the flagpole and get in line. If you're organizing a group outing, Alicia Herbst is listed as the contact for bus group visits, volunteer opportunities, fundraising opportunities, and bus tours.